Retail theft (shoplifting) charges in Pennsylvania: what to expect
The short answer: in Pennsylvania, a first retail theft of merchandise worth less than $150 is a summary offense, the lowest level of crime, but it is still a theft conviction. The grade climbs quickly: a second offense under $150 is a misdemeanor, any first or second offense of $150 or more is a first-degree misdemeanor, and a third offense, or merchandise worth more than $1,000, is a felony. ARD and other diversions count as prior offenses for grading. Many first cases can be resolved without a theft conviction if you act before the first court date.
How retail theft is graded, and the maximum penalties
Under 18 Pa.C.S. § 3929, the grade depends on the value of the merchandise and how many prior offenses you have. ARD and other preliminary dispositions count as priors.
| Situation | Grade | Maximum jail | Maximum fine |
|---|---|---|---|
| First offense, under $150 | Summary offense | 90 days | $300 |
| Second offense, under $150 | Misdemeanor, 2nd degree | 2 years | $5,000 |
| First or second offense, $150 or more | Misdemeanor, 1st degree | 5 years | $10,000 |
| Third or later offense (any value), over $1,000, or a firearm or motor vehicle | Felony, 3rd degree | 7 years | $15,000 |
Maximums, not typical sentences: most first cases end far below them. Courts can also order restitution. Value taken in one scheme, even from several stores, can be added together to set the grade. A separate offense, organized retail theft (18 Pa.C.S. § 3929.3), covers people who organize or run a theft-for-resale operation and is a felony starting at $2,500.
The letter from the store: civil demand
Many people get a letter from the store or its law firm demanding money weeks after the incident. That is a civil demand, not part of the criminal case. Pennsylvania law (42 Pa.C.S. § 8308) lets a merchant recover the merchandise or its value, plus a civil penalty of the value plus $150, and the merchant does not need a criminal conviction to make the claim.
If you pay a proper demand within 20 days, the store must give you a written release from further civil liability for that incident. Paying does not dismiss the criminal charge, and what you write back can be used as evidence, so talk to a lawyer before you respond.
Why a "minor" retail theft matters
Theft is a crimen falsi offense, a crime of dishonesty. It can be used to attack your credibility if you ever testify, and employers, landlords, schools and licensing boards treat it more seriously than many other low-level offenses. Because every retail theft counts as a prior for the next one, how the first case ends matters a great deal.
What happens next, step by step
1. Stop and citation
Store staff can detain you for a reasonable time if they have probable cause. Police then issue a citation (summary cases) or file a criminal complaint (misdemeanors and felonies), often by mail.
2. First court date
Summary citations go to a hearing before the magisterial district judge. Misdemeanor and felony cases start with a preliminary arraignment and preliminary hearing at the same local court.
3. Resolution options
Depending on the county and your record: dismissal, a diversion program, ARD, a reduction to a non-theft offense, a negotiated plea or a trial.
4. Clearing the record
ARD ends in expungement. Summary convictions can be expunged after five years without a new arrest, and many older convictions can be sealed under Clean Slate.
Defenses and ways to protect your record
- Intent. Retail theft requires intent to deprive the store. Concealment creates a presumption of intent, but it can be rebutted. Self-checkout errors, items left in a cart or bag, and distraction are common real-world explanations.
- Video and the stop. Store video often shows more, or less, than the incident report says. How long and how you were detained also matters.
- Value. Grading turns on value. Whether items are counted at the right price, and whether amounts were properly combined, can change the grade.
- Diversion and ARD. Many first cases qualify for a program that ends in dismissal and expungement. ARD counts as a prior for future retail thefts, so it is worth comparing every option.
- Non-theft resolutions. In some cases the charge can be resolved as a non-theft offense, which avoids a crime-of-dishonesty conviction.
Common questions
Is shoplifting a felony in Pennsylvania?
It can be. A first offense under $150 is a summary offense, but retail theft becomes a third-degree felony on a third or later offense of any value, when the merchandise is worth more than $1,000, or when the item is a firearm or a motor vehicle. Value from one scheme across several stores can be added together.
I got a letter from the store demanding money. Do I have to pay it?
That is a civil demand under 42 Pa.C.S. § 8308, separate from the criminal case. The law lets a merchant seek the value of the merchandise plus $150, and paying a proper demand within 20 days gets you a written release from further civil liability. Paying it does not end the criminal charge, so talk to a lawyer before you respond.
Does ARD count against me on a later retail theft?
Yes. Pennsylvania's retail theft statute counts ARD and other preliminary dispositions as prior offenses when grading a later retail theft. That means ARD on a first case can turn a second case under $150 into a misdemeanor instead of a summary offense.
It's only a summary offense. Do I need a lawyer?
A summary retail theft is still a theft conviction, a crime of dishonesty that shows up on background checks and counts as a prior offense if you are ever charged again. A lawyer can often work toward a dismissal, a diversion program or a non-theft resolution that protects your record.
The store says I hid items. Can I still fight the charge?
Yes. The law presumes intent when someone conceals unpurchased merchandise, but that presumption can be challenged. Store video, receipts, how the stop happened and what was said all matter, and mistakes such as an item left in a cart or a self-checkout error are common defenses.
Can a retail theft be removed from my record?
Often. ARD ends in dismissal and expungement. A summary conviction can be expunged after five years without a new arrest, and Pennsylvania's Clean Slate law and limited-access petitions can seal many older misdemeanor and some felony theft convictions.
Charged with retail theft? Talk to Michael before your first court date.
Free, confidential consultation. Michael P. Murphy defends retail theft cases in Montgomery, Bucks, Berks, Lehigh and Northampton Counties. More: retail theft defense · expungement. This guide is general information, not legal advice about your situation, and the law can change. Sources: 18 Pa.C.S. §§ 3929, 3929.3, 1101, 1104, 1105; 42 Pa.C.S. § 8308; Pa.R.E. 609; Pennsylvania record-clearing law (18 Pa.C.S. §§ 9122, 9122.1–9122.2).